The Sheriff Went to Cincinnati by Henry E. Giles EQMM, March 1951 ★★★★★ Dear Western Readers, You might be wondering why Gunsmoke & Grits is venturing into an issue of Ellery Queen's Mystery Magazine . Let me clarify right off the bat: I'm not shifting genres here. I managed to track down a well-preserved copy of Vol. 17, No. 88 from March 1951, because I wanted to read a specific short story, “ The Sheriff Went to Cincinnati ,” credited to Henry E. Giles but written by his wife, Janice Holt Giles. While it's not a classic Wild West tale, the story unfolds in the Kentucky hills. In Janice Holt Giles's biography by Dianne Watkins Stuart, she recounts a letter Janice wrote to her agent revealing that Henry claimed to have "started writing a little"—which was quite the stretch—after submitting his first short story to Ellery Queen's Mystery Magazine for their 1949 annual mystery contest and winning the first story award along with a $150 prize. “ The Sh...